Home » Racing & Sport » What’s The Question?

What’s The Question?

...if the answer's a Maiden Handicap?

Everyone knows what’s wrong with racing.

Everyone has an opinion, and that’s the way of the world.

But do you ever get the feeling that the world isn’t as thoughtful as it once was?

Not that we get things right or wrong more, just that we haven’t mulled it over as much, that we arrive at answers by choosing a side?

Tony Mincione writes that in his opinion, nothing highlights racings’ problems more than have a MAIDEN PLATE offered as a MAIDEN HANDICAP.

We must ask: if this is the answer, then what is the question?  Whose side is it?

So maiden races are for horses that have never won a race.  It’s racing’s entry-level.

Sure there are some practical concessions, there is a simple WFA formula so that 3-year-olds and 4-year-olds meet, there is a sex allowance to encourage fillies to race against colts, and we keep 2 year- olds separate until they are closer to 3.

But in principle, the entry-level of the sport is to be able to win a race before choosing your career path. You can compete, without worrying about merit ratings or conditions, and always against horses who have never won.

Over time it has proven to be an excellent system.  Roughly speaking, the horse population has been divided into two groups, horses who never win a race and those that win 1 and more.

Ipi Tombe – sets Dubai alight

The South African racing we are all so proud of when our horses go overseas and shock them, from London News, Sun Classique,Victory Moon, Ipi Tombe to JJ the Jet Plane and Variety Club etc, are horses that are standing on the shoulders of a system that asked only one condition: that the first test that everyone goes through is the same entry exam for all, a not negotiable benchmark where your first victory is fair, without concessions or handicap advantages.

The brilliance of this is that as a breeding country we can trust that a winner in the studbooks is exactly that.

That if a mare has a winner, we understand what it means.  If a stallion has a winner over a mile, we know what that means.  We know what it means if you win in your first two runs (Met and July fields consist of horses where 9 out of 10 have won in their first two starts).

Heavy Metal wins the Durban July in 2013
(Picture: JACKIE CLAUSEN 6/7/2013)

It’s a basic separating the wheat from the chaff.

This may not seem a big deal, but horse racing is a game of so many variables that after so many advances, after great statistical improvements in form guides, after digital timing, after computer analysis, money still doesn’t guarantee anyone success.  So the benefit of an entry benchmark gives you the kind of security you see in UK racing where certain pointer races go back 100 years or more.  It’s not tradition for tradition’s sake – but keeping some things that are tried and tested, and true.

Other than the individuals who would benefit in a race from being weighted to win in a maiden, who would want this?

Now altering conditions so that you do not win because you are ready and able, but because you have failed in your previous runs. Again, who wants this, and why?  I suspect operators and not fans or participants.  And probably not punters who had given up on handicaps and mainly play on maiden races.

Breeders must hate this – your mare has a horse who should have won but doesn’t because a proven bad horse gets a 2 or 3 or 8kg advantage. 

To make it even worse, you then enter the handicapping system (post maiden handicapping system) with an advantage that you keep.  If you did receive 8kgs, and you win by a short head, the horse you beat will still have to give you say 7kgs.

Ding Dong wins the 1967 Metropolitan Handicap

Ding Dong wins the 1967 Metropolitan Handicap

We started with a tiered system of racing in South Africa and introduced merit for handicapping believing that it would only affect handicapping.

What actually happened is it consumed everything between Maiden races and Feature races. It changed the whole landscape at the expense of good horses, and at the expense of smaller yards.

Part of horseracing is competition and consequently the pursuit of excellence.  The competition part comes alive because there is this 1 in 10 attrition factor.

Most races have about 10 runners and only 1 can win. As you win you move up with horses that did the same as you.  By the time you are a 4 or 5-time winner (without handicapping), you are part of the top 5%.  With handicapping some other horse will get your spot.

Each Maiden Handicap we have will make rewarding success fairly, more difficult.  If this were a school system, there is a time to help the battler, but also a time to hold back those who haven’t made the grade.

Maiden Handicaps is how you promote those who haven’t grasped reading yet.  Who wants that?

Ed – Phumelela Racing Executive Patrick Davis confirmed earlier this week that Maiden Handicaps are being trialled on the Highveld.

Have Your Say

Comments Policy
The Sporting Post encourages everyone to feel free to comment in the spirit of enlightening the topic being discussed, to add opinions or correct errors. All posts are accepted on the condition that The Sporting Post can at any time alter, correct or remove comments, either partially or entirely.

All posters are required to post under their real and verified names, you can adjust your display name on your account page or to send corrections privately to the Editor. The Sporting Post will not publish comments submitted anonymously or under pseudonyms.

The views of any individuals that are published are NOT necessarily the views of The Sporting Post.

8 comments on “What’s The Question?

  1. Mgram says:

    I think that the most important factor here is the purse raced for. Who benefits from offering lower stakes?

  2. Graham Hurlstone-Jones says:

    If it works don’t repair it…..Why is the maiden handicap being introduced ? More fiddling while Rome burns….Bubble gum racing but no one will listen, this is all done in the Ivory Towers….

  3. joao says:

    You can call it what you want, from bubble gum racing to cartoon racing. The purists claim a system based on an utopia that is simply just not possible in South Africa and almost anywhere else in the world where breeding “in-house” breeding is the cornerstone and main supplier of the product.

    Since i started in racing I have been watching the same or very similar colours partaking in the Arc, Debry, 1000 gns, 2000 gns etc etc etc. SA cannot do the same because we are playing off a field that is not as expansive as the UK for example.

    Let me elaborate further, for the size of country we have we certainly breed too many horses by too many breeders. We certainly lack 3-5 dominant forces (coolmore-godolphin-juddmonte-HH The A Khan-Sheik Maktoum)

    That means that in theory every man has a chance at glory in SA and therefore we breed like rabbits and sell onwards. This has resulted in a population of horses that is bottom heavy, this situation gets worse because we don’t have a system of self handicapping (claiming races) we only have what we dealt with. Maidens – A gazzilion handicaps- pattern races.

    Handicaps in SA are NOT treated the same way handicaps are treated in the UK. Handicaps in SA are “a race for a horse to run in” In the UK a handicap is a target for a horse to run in. The trainer does NOT have to run it in a handicap, he can choose other race types. Handicaps in the UK are plotted and planned for. The art of handicapping a horse or indeed finding a well handicapped horse is the beauty of the game. In SA that does not work. horse run for the sake of running as its another race along the horses career.

    now we get to maiden handicaps , I fail to see what the fuss is. Race 8 at Scottsville is a Maiden but basically with 9 of the 15 runners having a Handicap Mark for all intents and purposes its a Maiden Handicap. I get it that in a “true” MR Handicap there is also a weight spread but why is that so bad?

    As for winning a Maiden being the stepping stone to greatness of course you can track all those horse back to winning a Maiden , that is winning a Maiden is the route in SA.

    Personally i reckon Maidens should have varied prize money. They should range from R50 000 Maidens to R200 000 Maidens with attached requirements for partaking in those races but dismissing HC Maidens is a bad thing as i feel we need them but they cannot be a stand alone addition to the programme. We also need races – sales whereby the population can be moved around from trainer to trainer moving stables buying and selling horses in training is the ultimate true barometer for the population.

  4. Prasheen Harrimohan says:

    Tt people have no bloody common sense on the TV it showed number 3 was Scratched at Saratoga on the 22.8. Race 6but the result was 1a by 3 where the f*** is their common sense how the he’ll do we punt. Could someone please sort this s*** out and put common sense ppl to work at tt. Mr editor please help

    1. Editor says:

      Prasheen, we asked them via email yesterday to assist with these US saddlecloth numbers per your query.
      No response as yet

  5. Armchair jockey says:

    You make many good points Joao. We do fuss to much over tradition.

  6. Short says:

    What type of race does the
    operator need to introduce to confuse punters further?

  7. Art says:

    Ed on an entirely different note.Somebody at TAB decided to change the screen format for declaring the dividends.On a laptop it might be ok but on a smartphone it is a pain in the butt.Can you find out the reason for the sudden change as the old screen format was perfect.Do they do this to irritate us punters or is this another grand plan to just piss us off.Please TAB have another look at your screen format and try and condense it so it is easier on the eye on a smartphone

Leave a Comment

‹ Previous

Richest Flat Handicap At York Today

Next ›

Milnerton’s Father-Daughter Partnership

Popular Posts