Duke’s Daughter – Appeal Lodged

Gr1 appeal after controversial demotion decision

Duke Of Marmalade

Duke Of Marmalade

Drakenstein Stud’s outstanding new sire Duke Of Marmalade was represented by his fourth individual European classic winner in 2015 when his daughter Simple Verse finished first past the post in Saturday’s Gr1 Ladbrokes St Leger.

Sadly, the gutsy filly was demoted to second, following a stewards inquiry, and Bondi Beach was promoted to first. The Ralph Beckett trained Simple Verse, bidding to become the first of the fairer sex since User Friendly in 1992 to win the St Leger, was thus placed second.

It was another one and three quarter lengths back to third place finisher Fields Of Athenry with G2 Great Voltigeur Stakes hero Storm The Stars back in fourth place.

Trainer Ralph Beckett plans to appeal the decision, after a fiercely fought finish in which both Bondi Beach and Simple Verse appeared to lean on each other. He said post-race, “”I’m astonished apart from anything else. There is no consistency in the rules. Whatever way you look at it, both horses leaned on each other. Are you really saying that it was our horse’s fault? Are you really saying that? I don’t think I can say that.

The filly, who had won three of her four previous outings, put up a bold showing nonetheless, despite pulling hard early on and suffering notable interference from the eventual “winner” in the closing stages of the St Leger.

Simple Verse, who is out of the Sadler’s Wells mare Guantamera, had won the Gr3 Lillie Langtry Stakes at her previous outing for owner Qatar Racing.

Clearly a top notch filly, Simple Verse confirmed her status as arguably the leading staying filly of her generation with her remarkable run in Saturday’s classic, the final leg of the British Triple Crown, and further big race success should come her way before too long.

Duke Of Marmalade’s other classic winners are Star Of Seville (French Oaks), Nutan (German Derby) and Sound Of Freedom (Italian 1000 Guineas). The versatile former Cartier Champion has also been represented by group/graded winners in 2015 over trips ranging from 1000m to 3200m.

And subsequently…

An appeal against the controversial demotion of Ladbrokes St Leger first past the post Simple Verse will be held next week. The BHA confirmed on Monday an appeal had been lodged by connections of the runner-up, who lost the race to Bondi Beach in the stewards’ room following the race.

An initial appeal date of Thursday this week was changed due to issues with the availability of one of the participants’ counsel. The BHA issued three options – September 22, 23 or 25.

Explaining their main grounds for appeal on Sunday, Redvers said: “The big thing that has been mentioned everywhere is inconsistency and that’s the only thing I’ve got to say.”

SP Editorial staff & www.capebreeders.co.za

Have Your Say - *Please Use Your Name & Surname

Comments Policy
The Sporting Post encourages readers to comment in the spirit of enlightening the topic being discussed, to add opinions or correct errors. All posts are accepted on the condition that the Sporting Post can at any time alter, correct or remove comments, either partially or entirely.

All posters are required to post under their actual name and surname – no anonymous posts or use of pseudonyms will be accepted. You can adjust your display name on your account page or to send corrections privately to the EditorThe Sporting Post will not publish comments submitted anonymously or under pseudonyms.

Please note that the views that are published are not necessarily those of the Sporting Post.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Share:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter

Popular Posts

From Chaos To Reform

Charl Pretorius writes in his Off The Record column on the 4Racing website that owners, trainers and racing fans are gravely concerned about the state of our industry

Read More »